
It seems as though everyone is jumping on the "hate the Braves and watch them burn" bandwagon. After 14 years of success, it was bound to happen. Now, John Donovan is reminding everyone that the
Braves are not only bad this year, but most likely, they will be bad next year and a few years after that as well. Fair enough. I could see his point, but I like to argue. Therefore, I'll give you a different point of view that is as unbiased a Braves' perspective as possible (which means that it will be fairly unbiased, but I can't promise complete lack of bias). The Braves can indeed contend next season.
Let's start with the lineup because at least that's less muddled than the pitching staff. I'll go around the diamond. Behind the plate, Brian McCann is a three-time All-Star and the future leader of this team, and he won't be going anywhere for a very long time. He'll most likely hit fifth next year unless the Braves fail to grab a power-hitter this offseason, and in that case, he'll probably hit fourth. At first, the Braves have Casey Kotchman who is a downgrade from Teixeira, but when you figure in salary, it isn't too bad. Kotchman has a bright future, but he won't make many All-Star teams. He'll likely hit .290 with around 20 HR next season and top out around 25 by the time he leaves after 2011. He'll likely hit sixth. At second, Kelly Johnson continues to get better offensively but struggle defensively. As he begins to enter his prime, one can look for a .280 average with 15-20 HR for next season. Pretty good for a second baseman, and he'll hit eighth. Yunel Escobar will play short, and he has the brightest future outside of McCann. However, he'll need a bit more power to be an All-Star unless his BA rises, but he's still going to be good. He'll continue to hit second in the order and do it well. Chipper again will be playing third, but the question becomes for how many games. If he can play 140 games, he'll be very effective. The outfield brings questions. In left, no one knows who will be there, but with Pat Burrell and Adam Dunn available, the Braves can make a significant offensive upgrade but lose defense. They would hit fourth. If it ends up not being either of those and the Braves need an in-house option, Brandon Jones could be an answer, but he doesn't exactly scream power. In Mississippi, Reid Gorecki is having a decent year, but at age 28, he hardly inspires confidence. The Braves need outside help on this one. In center, Gregor Blanco has earned the nod in center and in the leadoff spot. Plus, he adds much needed speed to the lineup. There's no reason to go outside for a center-fielder, but in-house guys such as Josh Anderson and Jordan Schafer could steal the job. In right, they'll have Jeff Francoeur. There are two possible directions for him. Either he'll snap out of it and rediscover '07 with the help of McCann this offseason, or he'll be stubborn and continue his collapse. I'll be optimistic, but he still doesn't inspire thoughts of .270 with 20 HR, although I think it's definitely possible. He has the talent, and as most scouts say, if he could do it once, he can do it again. This offseason, he needs to forget the weight room and enter the batting cage. Overall, this lineup isn't terrible. If they can add Wren's "one piece" in a power-hitter for the four spot, the lineup will look a lot like this year, which should have been good but we all know how that turned out. Essentially, the four spot (LF) would equal Tex, but Kotchman brings an upgrade to our left field situation. A better Frenchy would be the final key. Again, it doesn't inspire too much confidence, but I can see what Wren means by being a piece away here. The problem becomes what type of offense we are. Right now, the Braves are a power-hitting mentality in a semi-power body. Either they need to add power or add speed. One thought would be to trade Johnson and a throw in like Chuck James for a good young power-hitter or a young pitcher (either a really good reliever type or a pretty good starter), and then bring up Lillibridge to add speed and a better glove (he supposedly has good pop, but the average may be worse; still, it would be worth a chance). The future power is unfortunately in Single A right now in Freddy Freeman and Jason Heyward, so they won't be here for at least two more years (AA next year and AAA the year after if they don't hide them too long in High A next year). Tyler Flowers could bring power, but as a catcher/first baseman, he doesn't seem to have a spot unless he can play LF (they'll suffer the defense for the offense he could generate).
As for the bench, things look good. Sammons will be the backup, and he should be an upgrade to Corky Miller. Infante needs to stay and continue to be the utility guy. Nitram Odarp will also be an excellent backup infielder. Greg Norton will then be a good guy to keep and add power off the bench as well as his defensive versatility. Next, Josh Anderson would be a great guy to bring up to utilize his speed and defense in the outfield to handcuff with Dunn or Burrell.
In the rotation, the Braves need serious help. With Hudson out for all of next year (I'm being pessimistic here), they need an ace. Luckily, a few will be available in the offseason in Sabathia, Sheets, and Burnett. I'll cross Burnett out now. One of Sabathia and Sheets would be a great start. That would leave Sabathia/Sheets, Jurrjens, Campillo, Morton, and Reyes/Tommy Hanson (a really good AA guy having an outstanding year; with the Braves pushing pitchers, he could very well be here next year). I'd be more comfortable adding a decent guy like Derek Lowe, who has pitched extremely well and with his age he won't command more than 3 years, to help the rotation. At that point, the rotation would be Sabathia/Sheets, Lowe, Jurrjens, Campillo, and Morton/Hanson. That would be pretty good, but it still has its problems. Sheets (or Sabathia because of workload) could get hurt, but all pitchers could get hurt. Lowe could become 36 and stink up the joint. Jurrjens may not be ready for the responsibility, but I have complete faith in him. Campillo could realize he's a Mexican leaguer, and the rest of the NL could kill him. Yet, I like his chances with that changeup and his determination (I love Campy). Morton hasn't been terribly impressive, but he's had signs of brilliance. Hanson is young and inexperienced, but if he's the best you got, he's the best you got. Overall, the rotation could be pretty good, but we're all out of depth.
As for the bullpen, oh God. Gonzalez could be a very good closer, and at a year and months after TJ, his arm should be healthy. Soriano needs to be shut down, but he still may not be completely healthy with his history. Moylan may not be back until May, but he may not be effective until probably June or July, if then. Boyer has been durable this year, but we all know when guys make a jump in innings in one year (Injuries!). Bennett has been great for the Braves and should be the long reliever again. After that, the Braves have a few options. They could bring back Ohman, but I doubt they'll do that. Another is Jorge Julio, who has been great but still has control problems, but he wouldn't be bad for middle relief. Phil Stockman and Zach Schreiber could also come in with their great stints in Richmond. Don't forget about Acosta (or maybe we should). The question becomes a left-handed reliever other than Gonzalez. Would Reyes be a thought? Could the bullpen increase his productivity? Is it too early to change him? The bullpen could very well be a strength next year, especially if the rotation can pitch more innings, which if the rotation looks as described above, it very well could.
Is Wren being too optimistic with his "few pieces" approach? Maybe. The Braves are only a few "pieces" away, but unfortunately, those pieces are more like chunks. They need a power-hitting LF, ace SP, and a reliable and good SP. The problem will be the competition to get these pieces as they won't be the only ones after them. Yet, the Braves will have about $40 mil to play with, so there won't be any excuses. If Wren is willing to spend, this team can contend (like the rhyme).
Blanco CF
Escobar SS
Jones 3B
Dunn/Burrell/trade guy LF
McCann C
Kotchman 1B
Francoeur RF
Johnson/Lillibridge 2B
Sheets/Sabathia
Lowe ?
Jurrjens
Campillo
Morton/Reyes/Hanson/trade guy
Gonzalez CP
Soriano SU
Moylan SU
Boyer
Bennett
Ohman?
Julio/Schreiber/Stockman/Acosta/random pickup(s)/Reyes?
Trade Bait --> Johnson/Lillibridge, James/Reyes/Morton, Anderson/Blanco, Francoeur (although they'd be selling really low)